The authors set out to determine whether clinician visual attention can serve as a supervisory signal for an existing ECG deep-learning model. The framing aimed to separate true gaze-driven, case-specific learning from a population mean viewing prior and from diagnostic-performance preservation. Investigators used three publicly available, de-identified resources: an eye-tracking dataset for 12-lead ECG interpretation, PTB-XL, and LUDB. The manuscript states that no new human data were collected and that all datasets were publicly available before the analysis began.
A pretrained 23-output ECG network provided the starting point. The study team fine-tuned that network using a gaze-only loss function. The report indicates cross-validation folds in which eight ECGs per fold provided the gaze supervision signal; the source did not provide additional hyperparameter or optimizer details beyond this high-level description. Readers should note that the authors explicitly compared real clinician gaze targets to matched control targets—uniform and permuted gaze maps—to test whether any observed effect depended on correctly matched human viewing.
Data indicated modest improvements in held-out gaze cosine similarity after gaze-only tuning. The cohort of consultant readers showed cosine similarity rising from 0.858 to 0.872; all clinicians combined rose from 0.884 to 0.898. Those are small, measurable gains. The study team observed that an untrained mean gaze derived from the training folds agreed substantially better (0.929 for consultants and 0.951 for all clinicians), implying a strong mean-gaze population prior that the model could exploit without learning case-specific gaze patterns.
The authors evaluated whether model importance maps, estimated via lead occlusion, aligned with clinician gaze. Concordance between lead-occlusion importance and gaze was weak: the mean Spearman ρ reported was 0.236. That low correlation suggests limited correspondence between where the model places importance and where clinicians looked during interpretation in this experiment. The source supplies the correlation summary but does not expand on lead-level or rhythm-specific subanalyses.
The team tested diagnostic discrimination on an external set of 2,198 PTB-XL fold-10 ECGs. Macro AUROC fell from 0.922 before gaze-only tuning to 0.893 after gaze-only tuning. Investigators ran matched-control arms using uniform and permuted gaze targets; those controls also produced similar reductions in diagnostic performance. The authors reported these results to argue that diagnostic deterioration following gaze-only tuning was not uniquely attributable to correctly matched clinician gaze maps.
In a post hoc experiment the authors combined PTB-XL diagnostic cross-entropy loss with gaze loss during training. Macro AUROC for the diagnostic-only, real-gaze, uniform, and permuted arms hovered at approximately 0.923. Despite preserved discrimination under joint training, the study team observed that real-gaze targets were barely fitted even on training ECGs: cosine similarity moved only from 0.858 to 0.860. That near-stagnant fit indicates the network prioritized diagnostic loss over matching clinician gaze when both objectives were present.
The investigators reported that gaze-only optimisation can engage its intended target but did not appear to produce case-specific learning beyond a population viewing prior. Matched-control experiments (uniform and permuted targets) suggested that the observed drop in diagnostic performance with gaze-only tuning was not due to correctly matched clinician gaze. The authors therefore argue that claims attributing model behaviour or learning to human viewing require at minimum a mean-gaze baseline, a matched-null control, and function-preserving diagnostic controls. Limitations described in the source include sparsity of the gaze supervision experiment and the observation that gaze targets were barely fitted during joint training. The manuscript did not provide additional methodological details such as full training hyperparameters or per-lead analysis granularity. Remaining unanswered questions recorded by the authors include whether richer or more numerous gaze training examples would enable case-specific learning, and whether alternative supervisory formulations could yield clinically meaningful gains without degrading diagnostic discrimination.