PLOS One editors issued an Expression of Concern regarding the 2022 article titled "Coordination of agricultural informatization and agricultural economy development: A panel data analysis from Shandong Province, China." The notice, published November 13, 2026, records that a subset of the sources cited in the original article were later retracted. The editors, identified as the notice authors, advise readers to interpret the 2022 paper with caution. The Expression of Concern is openly available and carries DOI 10.1371/journal.pone.0362715.
The statement is terse. It reports the core issue—post-publication retractions of cited works—and it directs readers to treat the affected article cautiously. The notice itself does not present additional data or corrections to the original article’s analyses. It functions as a formal editorial alert rather than as a detailed investigation report.
The editors specified five references from the Sun et al. 2022 paper that were retracted after that paper was published. Those references are numbered 4, 10, 36, 38, and 43 in the article’s bibliography. The Expression of Concern states these retractions occurred subsequent to the 2022 article’s publication, but the notice does not elaborate on the content of those references, the grounds for their retraction, or the timing of each retraction relative to the 2022 paper.
Because the notice limits itself to identifying the affected reference numbers, readers seeking further detail must consult the original references, the retraction notices for those works, or the affected article to trace where those citations were used. The editorial notice does link to the original Sun et al. paper, enabling verification of which statements and analyses cite those references.
The Expression of Concern was published by the PLOS One Editors on November 13, 2026. The notice includes a formal citation: The PLOS One Editors (2026) Expression of Concern: Coordination of agricultural informatization and agricultural economy development: A panel data analysis from Shandong Province, China. PLoS One 21(11): e0362715. The DOI provided is 10.1371/journal.pone.0362715.
The affected research article is cited in the notice as: Sun Y, Zhao Z, Li M. Coordination of agricultural informatization and agricultural economy development: A panel data analysis from Shandong Province, China. PLoS One. 2022;17(9):e0273110. The notice supplies direct links to the original article page, the PDF, and external indexing records such as PubMed/NCBI and Google Scholar, allowing readers to access the primary text and examine its reference list.
The notice is distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License. It is presented with CrossMark metadata, so readers can check for further updates or editorial actions tied to the record.
The PLOS One Editors explicitly advise readers to interpret the 2022 Sun et al. article "with caution." That guidance is the primary action communicated in the notice. No correction, retraction of the 2022 article, or specific remedial editorial steps are listed in the Expression of Concern itself.
The notice includes the full bibliographic reference to Sun et al. 2022 and points readers to the article’s DOI and external index entries. Those links permit users to inspect the paper, review its bibliography, and follow up on the retraction notices for References 4, 10, 36, 38, and 43. The Expression of Concern also appears in the journal’s article metrics and comment sections, where readers can look for further developments or community discussion.
Limitations and outstanding questions
The Expression of Concern identifies that five cited works were retracted after publication but does not report how those retractions affect the analyses, results, interpretations, or conclusions presented in the Sun et al. 2022 article. The notice does not state whether the journal conducted a detailed post-publication review, whether the authors were contacted, or whether further editorial action (for example, a correction or retraction of the Sun et al. article) is under consideration. Those items are not reported in the Expression of Concern and must be resolved through subsequent editorial updates or by consulting the primary retraction notices for the cited references.
Readers who need to assess the integrity of the 2022 study should consult the Sun et al. article itself (PLoS One 2022;17(9):e0273110) and the individual retraction notices for References 4, 10, 36, 38, and 43. The editorial notice serves as an interim flag: it signals potential citation-related weaknesses that warrant caution but does not, on its own, quantify the impact on the paper’s findings.