A prospective clinical cohort of French and English bulldogs with BOAS underwent either staphylectomy or folded flap palatoplasty (FFP). Investigators enrolled dogs between December 2019 and September 2022. Each treatment arm contained eight dogs; assignment was decided by the attending surgeon’s procedural preference rather than random allocation. The central objective was straightforward: compare pre- and 4-week post-operative computed tomography (CT) measures of soft palate length, thickness, and volume, and determine whether FFP produced greater thinning than staphylectomy.
Surgeons performed cut-and-sew staphylectomy and FFP per established descriptions. For staphylectomy, resection of the caudal soft palate with simple continuous mucosal closure was used. The FFP technique involved a trapezoidal ventral mucosal incision, resection of portions of palatinus and levator veli palatini muscle bellies, folding of mucosa to reduce thickness, and mucosal apposition with absorbable monofilament. Investigators documented that the intended postoperative palatal position was to avoid any soft palatal tissue extending beyond the cranial to mid palatine tonsils.
CT imaging was performed pre-operatively and again at four weeks under the same sedation protocol. Scans used a 160-slice multidetector CT with standardized acquisition parameters and contrast administration. Dogs were sedated without intubation for the imaging, positioned in sternal recumbency with neck extension, and received oxygen supplementation and intra-scan monitoring. Postcontrast series were obtained and reformatted into transverse, sagittal, and dorsal planes for measurement.
Quantitative measures comprised soft palate length (caudal end of hard palate to caudal end of soft palate on sagittal images), maximum soft palate thickness (sagittal image), and volumetry derived from manual regions of interest (ROIs) on transverse images with slice-selected segmentation. An ACVR resident and a board-certified radiologist performed measurements; they were aware whether a scan was pre- or post-operative but blinded to breed and surgical procedure. Discrepancies in caliper placement or ROI delineation were resolved by consensus discussion between reviewers. The source did not report any objective numerical cutpoint used to define SP thickening; subjective radiologist assessment guided that designation.
Both surgical methods reduced soft palate length and volume when comparing pre- and post-operative CT within each group. The staphylectomy group showed a mean length reduction of 0.91 cm (95% CI 0.44–1.39 cm) and a mean volume reduction of 2.81 cm3 (95% CI 1.36–4.27 cm3). The FFP group showed a mean length reduction of 0.86 cm (95% CI 0.39–1.33 cm) and a mean volume reduction of 2.54 cm3 (95% CI 0.84–4.24 cm3). When adjusted comparisons between procedure groups were performed, the investigators observed no meaningful difference in the degree of SP shortening (adjusted mean difference 0.01 cm, 95% CI −0.33 to 0.35 cm) or in volume reduction (adjusted mean difference 0.32 cm3, 95% CI −0.52 to 1.16 cm3).
The FFP cohort experienced a mean reduction in maximal soft palate thickness of 0.30 cm (95% CI 0.10–0.50 cm). Staphylectomy did not produce statistically detectable thinning of the soft palate in this study. Investigators therefore reported that FFP resulted in greater thinning than staphylectomy while both procedures achieved comparable shortening and volumetric decreases.
Anesthesia and perioperative care followed institutional protocols. Dogs received pre-imaging sedation with dexmedetomidine and were later induced and intubated for surgery under inhalant anesthesia. Perioperative medications included short courses of antibiotics and anti-inflammatory agents as indicated. Post-operative management involved ICU respiratory monitoring, oxygen supplementation as clinically required, analgesia and GI supportive drugs when indicated, and outpatient prescriptions as needed.
The study recorded post-operative events, categorizing complications as major (tracheostomy, death/euthanasia) or minor (vomiting, regurgitation, incisional issues, aspiration pneumonia). The source reported data collection for these outcomes but did not provide extended functional outcome data beyond the four-week imaging and any airway re-examinations performed at that time point.
This was a single-center study with small treatment arms (eight dogs per group) and non-randomized group allocation determined by surgeon preference. Follow-up imaging occurred at a single four-week timepoint; longer-term structural remodeling and functional respiratory outcomes were not reported beyond that interval. The radiologists were aware of scan timing (pre vs post), which could introduce measurement bias, though they were blinded to procedure type. The source did not report objective numeric thresholds for defining soft palate thickening on CT, relying instead on subjective interpretation.
Unanswered clinical questions documented in the source include whether short-term imaging changes translate into sustained clinical improvement, how long any thinning effect of FFP persists, and whether findings generalize across wider brachycephalic populations or breeds beyond the included bulldogs. The study team noted these design constraints and did not present long-term outcome or randomized comparative efficacy data.