PLOS ONE published a correction to the article by Ali, Lafi, and Shalan after identifying that Fig 4C in the original paper overlapped with an image appearing in a separate 2025 Elsevier publication. The journal provided a corrected version of Fig 4 and made the original image data underlying the corrected panel available as S1 File. The correction explicitly states that the overlapping material from the Elsevier source is not offered under a CC BY license and therefore was excluded from the article’s licence. Download links for the corrected figure in PNG and TIFF formats were supplied in the notice.
The corrected figure caption and associated files describe the physical characterization of the niosomal formulation encapsulating cisplatin and vorinostat (referred to in the article as NIO-CIS-VOR). Data indicated a narrow particle size distribution with a peak centered at approximately 150 nm. Investigators reported a surface charge distribution with zeta potential values close to −10 mV, suggesting modest surface charge that the authors interpret as consistent with physical stability. Panel C of the corrected figure presents transmission electron microscopy (TEM) morphology; the correction supplies the original image file for that panel as supporting information.
The notice does not supply additional experimental parameters in the correction text itself. The correction caption focuses on reported size, charge, morphological representation via TEM, and the time-course stability plot; specific preparation methods, loading efficiencies, or measurement settings were not described within the correction notice and therefore are not restated here.
The corrected Fig 4 includes a 60-day stability profile at 4°C. Data shown in the caption indicate that the formulation’s hydrodynamic diameter (plotted in blue) and zeta potential (plotted in red) remained consistent over the 60-day period, which the authors present as evidence of good physical stability at refrigerated storage. The correction notice does not add new numerical timepoint values beyond the description in the figure caption; readers should consult the original article and the S1 File for the underlying image data and any raw values that may be supplied there.
The journal provided the corrected figure images for download (PNG and TIFF) and attached S1 File containing the original image data that underpin the corrected panel. The notice makes clear that the previously published Fig 4C contained material that originated in an Elsevier 2025 article; because that source is not CC BY, the content had to be excluded from the PLOS ONE license. The correction therefore both replaces the duplicated panel and clarifies the licensing status of the originally included material.
The corresponding author stated to the journal that the quantified results shown in Fig 4 were not affected by the identified image duplication. The correction notice records that statement, and provides the corrected figure alongside the original image data as S1 File so that readers can review the replacement panel and the underlying data. The notice does not claim changes to numerical conclusions presented elsewhere in the article; it limits the amendment to the figure panel content and related image data files.
The correction addresses an image overlap and provides replacement material plus the original image data file. The notice does not include expanded methodological details, additional numerical datasets, or revised experimental results beyond the figure replacement. The correction therefore leaves open specific technical questions that are not answered in the notice itself—for example, the correction did not report analytical settings for the TEM images, the precise methods used to determine the particle size distribution or zeta potential, nor did it add new quantitative tables for the 60-day stability measurements. Those experimental details, if required, must be sought in the original article or by contacting the authors directly.
Readers who need to verify the corrected panel or inspect raw image data can download the corrected images and S1 File linked in the correction notice. The correction concludes by citing the original PLOS ONE article and the DOI for the correction record; it does not report further editorial actions beyond the figure replacement and the licensing clarification.