Investigators reviewed 349 maternity-register and 291 newborn records from 12 facilities in Bungoma and a neighbouring county. They reported high median completeness at the variable level: registers had a median of 100% completeness (IQR 94.7–100), while newborn records had a median of 93.5% (IQR 84.8–100). Yet complete core documentation was uneven. A complete core register record appeared in 175 of 349 entries (50.1%, 95% CI 44.9 to 55.4). Newborn records fared worse: only 77 of 291 (26.5%, 95% CI 21.7 to 31.8) contained a full core data set.
Short, critical facts sit alongside more complex patterns. The dataset contained the key identifiers and primary neonatal measures often required for mortality or classification work, but record-level completeness fell short of ideal for many analytic purposes. The study team used the original, uncleaned abstractions for these assessments; the source did not report any post hoc data cleaning steps prior to the completeness metrics.
No values for maternal age, gestational age, birth weight or Apgar score were flagged as implausible by the prespecified plausibility rules. That said, date and chronology errors were common and systematic. The investigators noted a mismatch between recorded and date-derived length of stay greater than one day in 92 of 225 records where the comparison was possible (40.9%). In 35 of 257 records (13.6%) the recorded admission date preceded the recorded birth date, a clear chronological inconsistency that undermines timing-based analyses.
These timing fields — admission, discharge and event dates — showed the weakest reliability. The authors observed that such errors reduce confidence in analyses that rely on temporality, including length-of-stay studies, time-to-event survival analyses, and accurate derivation of care pathways.
The team compared chart-recorded classifications against rule-derived definitions for very-low-birth-weight and low-birth-weight (LBW) categories. Agreement was high for very-low-birth-weight, with kappa reported at 0.89 (95% CI 0.83 to 0.95). Agreement for LBW was more modest — kappa 0.53 (95% CI 0.32 to 0.73) — and the McNemar test indicated discordance (p=0.001) between recorded and rule-derived LBW classifications.
These findings mean weight-based classification can be reliable at the extreme low end, but routine LBW categorisation may misclassify cases when compared with algorithm-derived thresholds applied to raw weight entries. The source did not report sensitivity or specificity values beyond the kappa and McNemar statistics.
The mixed-methods design included ten facility readiness assessments and two provider key-informant interviews to explain quantitative patterns. The investigators reported that complete documentation was more likely when three or more record sources were present (adjusted prevalence ratio 1.80, 95% CI 1.05 to 3.08). Conversely, documentation completeness decreased for newborns who died (adjusted prevalence ratio 0.46, 95% CI 0.25 to 0.84).
Providers described documentation tasks as competing directly with clinical workload. That qualitative signal aligns with the quantitative associations: higher documentation burden and fewer redundancy checks corresponded with gaps in core-record completion, especially around events with high clinical acuity such as neonatal deaths.
The investigators judged that identification fields, gestational age, birth weight, and disposition were documented sufficiently to support classification and mortality analyses. However, timing fields (for example admission and discharge dates), maternal history items, and transport variables were not reliably recorded and therefore not analytically usable without targeted data cleaning or supplementary denominators.
A concrete consequence emerged: the team stated that preterm-birth prevalence could not be estimated from these routine records without an all-delivery denominator. The source did not report an alternative method for deriving a valid population denominator from the available records.
Ethical oversight was documented. The Institutional Scientific and Ethics Review Committee of Masinde Muliro University of Science and Technology granted approval (MMUST/ISERC/023/2026), and a national research licence and county authorisation were obtained; the ethics committee waived individual consent for the retrospective record review while key-informant participants provided informed consent.
The authors were explicit about limitations that affect analytic and surveillance applications: missing or inconsistent timing fields, incomplete maternal-history and transport variables, and the lack of an all-delivery denominator that prevents estimation of preterm-birth prevalence. The source did not provide strategies for generating an accurate denominator from the existing routine system, nor did it report post-collection correction methods beyond the descriptive and rule-based assessments documented above.