The authors set out to map whether preoperative preparation for robot-assisted surgery addresses patients' expressed needs and to examine how patient readiness has been evaluated in the literature. The review team reported using Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) guidance and PRISMA-ScR reporting standards. Twenty primary reports were included and organized across robotic surgical specialties. The review did not aim to test a single intervention; rather, investigators mapped approaches, outcomes, and the degree of concordance between what patients and caregivers said they needed and what preparation delivered.
Investigators searched six bibliographic databases from inception to September 10, 2026. They supplemented database searches with Google Scholar screening and citation searching. The abstract states that design-specific JBI tools supported critical appraisal. The review mapped primary reports against TIDieR-informed intervention reporting templates and organized outcomes into informational, psychological, decisional, and recovery domains. The specific databases searched and detailed inclusion/exclusion criteria are not reproduced in the abstract and therefore were not reported here.
The mapped reports described a variety of preparation approaches: visual aids, educational sessions, and psychological interventions were the main categories. Short, focused visual or educational formats often produced favourable immediate understanding ratings, investigators reported. Psychological approaches yielded favourable immediate emotional responses in some reports. Only one study, however, explicitly linked elicited patient or caregiver needs to the actual development of the preparation intervention; most alignment between stated needs and preparatory content was inferred by the review team rather than demonstrated within recipients.
Several common informational questions recurred across studies—what the robot does, how the surgeon interacts with the system, and general recovery expectations. At the same time, investigators found procedure-specific emotional and recovery requirements that varied by surgical specialty. Nurses and multidisciplinary teams can use the distinction between general robotic explanations and operation-specific recovery guidance to coordinate preparation content around patients' questions and recovery priorities, the authors suggested.
The review mapped outcomes into four domains. Informational outcomes most frequently measured immediate understanding or satisfaction with explanations. Psychological outcomes measured short-term emotional responses, including anxiety or reassurance, and in several reports these improved after targeted preparation. Decisional readiness and longer-term sustained understanding were rarely assessed across the mapped literature. Recovery-oriented outcomes appeared in some specialty reports but comparative and longitudinal evidence remained limited, investigators reported.
Because comparative trials and long-term follow-up were sparse, the evidence does not establish which preparation approaches produce durable benefits across different robotic procedures. The literature mapped short-term signals of effectiveness but offered limited guidance on sustained comprehension, decision confidence over time, or recovery trajectories tied to preparatory interventions.
The review team used TIDieR to assess how interventions were reported. They observed incomplete intervention descriptions that limit reproducibility. Essential details needed for replication—such as delivery personnel, timing relative to surgery, and full content scripts—were often missing from primary reports, according to the abstract. That lack of detail constrained the review's ability to identify a single most effective approach and hampered translation into practice.
Investigators identified several clear gaps. Comparative trials that evaluate different preparation formats head-to-head were limited. Longer-term assessments of sustained understanding and decisional readiness were rare. Only one study documented a formal needs-elicitation process directly informing intervention design; most preparation-need concordance remains inferred rather than demonstrated with recipients. The exploratory preparation-to-readiness framework proposed by the authors requires prospective evaluation in clinical settings. The abstract did not report trial sizes, specific outcome measures, or statistical findings, and those details were not available in the source summary. Future research priorities include prospectively testing the framework, improving TIDieR-compliant reporting of preparatory interventions, and measuring decisional and longer-term recovery outcomes to determine which approaches benefit patients across robotic surgical specialties.