Investigators conducted a randomized, single-blinded clinical trial at a pediatric dentistry department to compare topical lidocaine, benzocaine, and cryotherapy prior to buccal infiltration in children. One hundred healthy, literate children aged 7–10 years were enrolled and randomized equally into four groups (25 per group). The trial was registered at ClinicalTrials.gov (NCT07198022) and received institutional ethics approval; written consent was obtained from children and guardians.
Group allocations were: 10% lidocaine spray, 20% benzocaine gel (strawberry flavor), distilled water stored at +4 °C applied as cryotherapy, and 10% lidocaine spray cooled to +4 °C. All topical agents were applied to a dry mucosal surface with a cotton pellet, held gently for 20 seconds, and the child was asked to confirm perceived numbness before injection. Buccal infiltration anesthesia was then administered using 4% articaine with 1:100,000 epinephrine; a single operator deposited 1.5 mL slowly with a 27-gauge needle. Operator blinding was not feasible because of material differences; outcome assessors remained blinded.
The primary endpoint was pain during local anesthetic injection, measured with the Wong-Baker FACES Pain Rating Scale. Secondary patient-reported outcomes included the Modified Dental Anxiety Scale and the Facial Image Scale for anxiety. The study team reported no statistically significant differences among the four groups for pain scores or anxiety measures (all p > 0.05). Medians of the short ordinal scales were similar across arms, and the authors provided means with 95% confidence intervals as supplementary descriptors, while using nonparametric tests for inference.
These null differences indicate that, within this sample and using the applied protocols, cryotherapy produced pain and anxiety outcomes comparable to commonly used topical anesthetic agents. The trial did not report any subgroup analyses beyond sex comparisons for anxiety, and no significant anxiety differences were found between girls and boys.
Physiological monitoring included pulse rate and oxygen saturation measured at three time points: before topical application (pre-operative), during topical application (peri-operative), and during local anesthetic injection (post-operative). Pulse rate increased significantly from baseline to injection across the pooled sample (mean increase reported; p = 0.006), indicating autonomic arousal associated with the injection moment. The study team used Greenhouse-Geisser corrections where sphericity assumptions were violated.
No main effect of group and no group × time interaction were observed for pulse rate, meaning the temporal rise in pulse rate did not differ according to the topical intervention. Oxygen saturation values showed no significant main effects for time or group, and no interaction effect. Between-group differences for these physiological measures were not statistically significant.
Taste acceptability was assessed with a Three-Point Hedonic Scale. The trial found no significant differences in taste acceptability among the four interventions (p > 0.05). Behavioral compliance during injection was evaluated using the FRANKL Behavior Rating Scale. Here, investigators observed significantly higher FRANKL scores in the cryotherapy (distilled water) group compared with the gel and cooled-spray groups (p = 0.001). The authors labeled this result exploratory, noting it as a behavioral signal rather than a definitive efficacy claim.
No adverse events were reported during or immediately after procedures in any arm. The CONSORT flow indicated that all randomized participants completed the protocol and were included in analysis.
The study team applied repeated-measures ANOVA for normally distributed physiological variables and Kruskal-Wallis with post-hoc pairwise testing for ordinal and non-normally distributed outcomes. The sample size was powered for a one-way ANOVA effect-size estimate and enrolled 100 participants to allow for dropouts; in practice there were no post-randomization exclusions. Exact p-values and effect-size estimates (partial eta-squared or epsilon-squared as appropriate) were reported in the article. The authors provided a de-identified individual participant dataset (S1 Dataset) and a supporting data dictionary.
Ethical approvals and trial registration are documented. No funding or competing interests were declared by the authors.
The authors acknowledged several constraints: the trial was single-blinded because the operator could not be blinded to distinct topical materials; the FRANKL finding was exploratory and not adjusted for multiple secondary comparisons; and the study focused on asymptomatic primary-teeth procedures in a narrow pediatric age range, which limits generalizability. The source article states that confirmation by non-inferiority trials is needed before routine adoption of cryotherapy as a non-pharmacological alternative to topical anesthetics. These specific limitations and the call for dedicated non-inferiority designs are the final documented recommendations from the study team.