Preschool children placed in state care are considered to have elevated risk for a range of psychosocial and developmental concerns. This population-based study used routine 27–30 Month Health Review records collected in Scotland from April 2013 to March 2023 to quantify the prevalence of psychosocial health concerns among children in care compared with those not in care, and to examine how these differences vary across an area-level deprivation gradient.
The primary objective was to estimate prevalence of recorded psychosocial and developmental concerns in children in care and not in care, and to assess care-status differences stratified by deprivation. The authors emphasise population-level surveillance using administrative health review data as a means to identify early inequalities.
This was a cross-sectional, population-based analysis of routinely collected 27–30 Month Health Review data from the universal health review programme in Scotland between April 2013 and March 2023. The analytic sample included 7,887 children recorded as in care at the review and 445,547 children recorded as not in care.
The health review dataset provides standardized assessment at around 2.5 years of age, and the authors used the care status recorded at that review as the exposure of interest.
Exposure: care status at time of review, classified dichotomously as in care or not in care.
Outcomes: four categories of recorded concerns derived from the review data:
An aggregate indicator of any recorded concern (presence of one or more of the four categories) was also used as a primary outcome.
The analysis estimated crude prevalence, relative risks, and multivariable-adjusted odds ratios comparing children in care with children not in care. Models adjusted for child sex, age, ethnicity, and area-level deprivation. The investigators examined variation in adjusted associations across outcome categories and by deprivation fifths to characterise gradients in prevalence and inequity.
Psychosocial and developmental concerns were more common among children in care. The prevalence of any recorded concern was 29.0% (2,290 of 7,887) among children in care compared with 17.5% (77,836 of 445,547) among children not in care, yielding a relative risk of 1.66.
Prevalence was higher for children in care across all four outcome categories assessed.
After adjusting for sex, age, ethnicity and deprivation, children in care had higher odds of any recorded concern compared with children not in care (adjusted odds ratio [aOR] 1.86; 95% CI, 1.77–1.96).
Adjusted odds ratios varied by outcome type:
These findings indicate the largest relative difference by care status was observed for emotional, behavioral, and attentional concerns, while speech and communication concerns showed a smaller but still elevated association with being in care.
The study reports that relative inequities between children in care and not in care decreased with increasing area-level deprivation. Specifically, the adjusted odds ratio comparing children in care with children not in care for any recorded concern was highest in the least deprived fifth (aOR 2.61; 95% CI, 2.25–3.03) and lowest in the most deprived fifth (aOR 1.58; 95% CI, 1.45–1.72).
Prevalence of any recorded concern increased with deprivation within both care-status groups. The relative risk comparing the most deprived with the least deprived fifth of areas was 1.46 (95% CI, 1.29–1.66) among children in care and 2.34 (95% CI, 2.29–2.40) among children not in care.
These results indicate both an absolute increase in recorded concerns with greater deprivation and a pattern where the relative difference between care-status groups is larger in less deprived areas.
Using a decade of routine 27–30 Month Health Review data, the authors found clear evidence of early psychosocial health inequalities between children in care and those not in care. Children in care had higher prevalence of emotional, behavioral, attentional, social and communication concerns at preschool age, and adjusted analyses confirmed higher odds across all outcome categories.
Deprivation influenced both prevalence and relative inequities: concerns rose with increasing deprivation in both groups, but the relative gap between children in care and not in care was attenuated in the most deprived areas and amplified in the least deprived areas. The authors conclude that support for children in care and for children living in more deprived areas should be prioritised given the observed early inequalities.
Ethics committee/IRB of the University of Glasgow waived ethical approval for the work. The authors report that data are available via application to the NHS Scotland Public Benefit and Privacy Panel for Health and Social Care.
Declared funders include the Medical Research Council, the Chief Scientist Office, and the Economic and Social Research Council. The article is a preprint posted on medRxiv and has not been peer reviewed; the authors note it should not yet be used to guide clinical practice.
The source text is a medRxiv preprint abstract and reports aggregated results and model estimates; detailed methods, sensitivity analyses, and potential data limitations beyond those noted in the abstract are not included in the provided source. Where additional methodological or contextual details are required, the original preprint and supplementary material should be consulted.