The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services released a proposed rule intended to spur competition in Medicare Advantage and Part D markets while changing how plan quality is measured. Announced late Friday, the proposal comes from the Trump administration and includes several rule revisions designed to lower barriers to market entry for new plans, shift network adequacy testing, revise behavioral health network rules and alter the star ratings program.
CMS framed the package as changes that will let beneficiaries choose coverage on the basis of “quality, affordability, and access.” The agency said the proposals also align with Department of Health and Human Services priorities for supplemental benefits.
One of the central changes would alter when CMS requires organizations to demonstrate network adequacy. Under the proposal, new Medicare Advantage organizations would be required to show network adequacy during their first year of operation rather than as part of the initial application. CMS said this shift would remove a major barrier for new entrants and thereby encourage more competition in the MA market.
In another change affecting provider networks, CMS proposed to combine three specialty behavioral health categories — clinical psychology, clinical social work and outpatient behavioral health — into a single specialty group for network adequacy purposes. According to CMS, that consolidation would provide plans with more flexibility in building behavioral health networks.
The agency also noted it will make unspecified adjustments intended to strengthen competition among special needs plans. The proposal summary did not provide additional operational details about those changes.
CMS said it will narrow the star ratings program to focus on 15 measures. The proposed measure set is described as emphasizing clinical outcomes and patient experience while retaining select process measures in areas where performance remains low. CMS also plans to update the calculation methodology in ways meant to “raise the bar for achieving high ratings” — a step that would affect eligibility for quality bonus payments tied to star ratings.
By concentrating ratings on fewer measures and tightening scoring, the agency is signaling a shift toward rewarding higher performance on outcomes and patient experience rather than broader process metrics. The proposal did not enumerate the specific 15 measures in the announcement.
The proposed rule includes a provision to set a “healthy food” standard that Medicare Advantage plans should use for supplemental benefits providing food. CMS framed the change as aligning benefit spending with the Department of Health and Human Services’ Make America Healthy Again (MAHA) agenda. The agency said the standard would require food benefits to meet the Dietary Guidelines for Americans while preserving access to foods and nutritional products that providers recommend for patients’ medical needs.
HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. commented that the change would ensure Medicare food benefits support nutrition aimed at improving health and managing chronic disease. CMS said the move is part of a broader push to make prevention central to health care and to demand more value from Medicare dollars.
CMS Administrator Mehmet Oz, M.D., described the proposals as a way to create a Medicare Advantage marketplace that “rewards better care and better value” while giving beneficiaries information and options to make informed choices about their coverage.
HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. positioned the healthy food standard within the administration’s Make America Healthy Again agenda, emphasizing dietary alignment with federal guidelines and continued clinician discretion to recommend specific foods or nutritional products when medically necessary.
Medicare Advantage enrollment has been a focal point for federal regulators and policymakers because private plans now cover a substantial portion of Medicare beneficiaries. Changes to network adequacy rules and entry requirements could make it easier for insurers, especially smaller or newer entities, to enter or expand in local markets. By combining behavioral health specialties for adequacy purposes, CMS is seeking to simplify network-building for plans that must meet provider availability standards.
Adjustments to the star ratings program have implications for plan revenues and market positioning. Star ratings influence consumer choice and determine access to quality bonus payments; tightening the scoring methodology and narrowing the measure set could shift how plans prioritize investments in care management and patient experience initiatives.
The proposed healthy food standard affects supplemental benefit design. Medicare Advantage plans that offer meal or food benefits may need to ensure those offerings comply with the proposed Dietary Guidelines–aligned standard, while still accommodating provider-recommended items for specific patient needs.
The CMS announcement outlined broad policy shifts but did not provide a full list of the 15 star rating measures, nor did it include granular operational details for the changes to special needs plans. Timelines for implementation, public comment periods or precise technical specifications for the revised calculation methodology also were not reported in the agency summary presented in the announcement.
The CMS release presents a proposed rule; by statute, it will proceed through the federal rulemaking process. That typically includes a public comment period during which stakeholders — including insurers, provider organizations and patient advocates — can submit feedback. CMS will then review comments and may issue a final rule that could modify aspects of the proposal before it takes effect.
Stakeholders will likely scrutinize the proposed timing for network adequacy demonstrations, the combined behavioral health specialty category, the narrowed set of star measures and the details of the healthy food standard, particularly how Medicare Advantage plans must demonstrate compliance. The announcement did not specify dates for formal comment, finalization or implementation.
CMS’s proposed rule seeks to lower barriers for new Medicare Advantage entrants, streamline behavioral health network requirements, refocus star ratings on a smaller set of outcome- and experience-oriented measures, and require a Dietary Guidelines–based “healthy food” standard for supplemental benefits. The agency framed these moves as steps to expand beneficiary choice, improve care quality and ensure Medicare dollars support preventive and value-based services, while some implementation details remain to be defined during the rulemaking process.
Personalise this feed
Your specialty. Your sources. Your digest.
All set up in under 2 minutes.
Personalise this feed
Your specialty. Your sources. Your digest.
All set up in under 2 minutes.