Emergency medicine significantly depends on Independent Dispute Resolution (IDR), established under the No Surprises Act. This mechanism was designed to manage payment disputes concerning out-of-network services, particularly for patients receiving emergency care. With the law taking effect in 2022, the reliance on IDR has become increasingly crucial in the face of challenges to reimbursement structures.
Providers in this specialty have expressed concerns regarding historical contracts that have either been canceled or updated with substantial reductions in payment rates. Moreover, cases of downcoding — where insurers reduce the billed amount for services — have put a strain on existing in-network agreements, leading many groups to operate out of network. After transitioning to out-of-network status, reimbursements from insurers have decreased sharply. For some physicians, the compensation for life-saving visits has been alarmingly minimal.
This issue is substantiated by recent investigations from the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), the Government Accountability Office, and RAND, all of which have documented a significant downturn in reimbursement figures. In the absence of contracts and with inadequate payments often failing to cover basic visit costs, IDR serves as one of the remaining avenues for emergency medicine groups to sustain their operations. As negative narratives surrounding IDR continue to circulate, it is imperative for emergency physicians to demonstrate effective practices within this framework.
A common context for utilizing IDR involves out-of-network emergency physicians treating patients at in-network healthcare facilities. This scenario epitomizes the very rationale behind the No Surprises Act. Independent emergency medicine groups are not misusing IDR; instead, the system was explicitly designed with their operations in mind.
However, the process of determining eligibility for IDR is intricate. Depending on factors such as the funding of the patient’s health plan, a claim may require processing through state arbitration instead of the federal system. Additionally, claims that appear to be out of network might be connected to a network agreement via a third-party administrator. Insurers often contribute to confusion by omitting critical information, compelling independent groups to take on the task of clarifying these points.
This ongoing challenge highlights the need for these groups to stay informed about any missing information, payer-specific codes, and notices of ineligibility. Manual claim reviews are often inadequate to identify all issues effectively; thus, a systematic, technology-driven approach is necessary to ensure compliance and optimal outcomes.
Another critical aspect of succeeding in IDR is the pursuit of fair revenue claims. Offers submitted must reflect the actual value of the care provided rather than being inflated to maximize potential awards. According to data from the 2025 IDR public use files, the average reasonable offer among disputes related to emergency physicians was roughly three times the qualifying payment amount (QPA). This stands in contrast to the eye-catching headlines reporting offers that reach 50 to 100 times the QPA.
In fact, in-network payments by insurers can often significantly exceed the QPA, sometimes multiple times over. Yet, the landscape is evolving. Observations indicate many insurers have not fully engaged with the IDR process, and some show minimal participation. As they begin contesting these disputes more vigorously, independent groups must be prepared with well-supported cases. Strong evidence is often found beyond the initial claim forms. For instance, while the billing code CPT 99291 indicates critical care provision, detailed medical records present a far richer narrative of the patient’s condition, including symptoms and the complex interventions performed.
Extracting these details and contextualizing them with historical contract data and market conditions requires substantial effort, and artificial intelligence is well suited to facilitate this process. When paired with clinical and compliance knowledge, AI can help organizations present clear evidence, improving the likelihood of favorable IDR outcomes and minimizing skepticism from critics.
While IDR provides essential support, it is not a permanent solution. Many leaders among independent emergency medicine groups express a preference for being in-network with insurers under agreements that yield predictable payments, alleviating the necessity of constant dispute processes that can be burdensome.
When executed effectively, IDR can empower these groups to achieve better contract negotiations. A consistent track record of successful, eligible claims not only fortifies their negotiating stance but also encourages insurers to actively engage in negotiations. Until such arrangements are established, IDR will remain a critical backstop. Ultimately, fostering fair contracts must be the long-term objective to ensure the viability of emergency care services.
Personalise this feed
Your specialty. Your sources. Your digest.
All set up in under 2 minutes.
Personalise this feed
Your specialty. Your sources. Your digest.
All set up in under 2 minutes.