Transition readiness instruments for young people living with HIV were largely developed in high‑income settings and typically frame readiness around clinical competence and individual autonomy. The authors sought to examine how youth in a low‑ and middle‑income context understand the passage to adulthood and what methodological conditions shape those understandings. They used a participatory photovoice approach with peer facilitation to center young people's visual and collective interpretations of growing up while living with HIV in India.
The investigation was conducted in March 2026 using a participatory photovoice design. Sixteen youth living with HIV, aged 13–22 years, participated across two study sites in Karnataka (Bengaluru and Belgaum). Participants were supported to take photographs that represented their experiences of growing up and their expectations for the future; they then engaged in collective interpretation of these images. The study explicitly foregrounded peer facilitation as part of the methodological design.
Participants numbered 16 and ranged in age from 13 to 22 years. The two study locations were Bengaluru and Belgaum in Karnataka, India. The source did not report additional sociodemographic or clinical details in the abstract; those details would be available in the full text or supplementary material as needed.
In March 2026 participants completed the primary photovoice activities. A subset of six participants returned in May 2026 for a reflective discussion focused on the method itself and on how the process influenced their interpretations. Collective interpretation and iterative discussion of images were core to the data collection strategy.
Participants articulated independence not primarily as clinical self‑management or autonomous decision‑making but as the capacity to sustain others. Independence was framed in relational and reciprocal terms—ability to support family members and meet obligations—rather than in the individualistic terms common to many transition readiness tools developed in high‑income contexts.
When identifying principal risks associated with transition to adulthood, participants located these risks in relational and social domains rather than in clinical domains. Stigma, community expectations, and family obligations emerged as central concerns shaping youths’ visions of the future. These priorities contrast with transition instruments that emphasize clinical competence, adherence, and self‑management as primary indicators of readiness.
An important methodological observation was that reciprocal obligation—mutual responsibility within relationships—was absent from the initial analytic codebook but surfaced through participants’ visual metaphors and group interpretation. The authors emphasize that peer facilitation operated as a methodological condition influencing both what participants produced and how findings were interpreted, rather than serving only as an additive participatory element. They recommend that photovoice studies explicitly report who exercised interpretive authority during analysis and dissemination.
Based on participant input, the study suggests that preparation for transition should begin earlier than is often assumed: participants recommended starting around age 12. The findings imply that current definitions of transition readiness that prioritize clinical skills and individual autonomy may miss critical social, familial, and community dimensions important to youth in low‑ and middle‑income settings. The authors propose that participatory photovoice can broaden prevailing conceptualizations and inform more youth‑responsive assessment tools.
The authors report having obtained ethical approvals from Johns Hopkins University IRB (IRB00033960), YRGCARE IRB (IRB 00001423), and University of Washington IRB (Study No. 00025166). Participant consent procedures and relevant reporting guidelines were followed, according to the declarations. All study data are available upon reasonable request to the authors. The article is published as a medRxiv preprint and has not been peer reviewed; the authors and readers are reminded that findings should not be used to guide clinical practice without further validation.
This photovoice study with peer facilitation found that youth living with HIV in Karnataka prioritize relational capacity and social protection when defining independence and assessing risks during transition. Reciprocal obligation emerged as a salient theme through participants’ visual narratives. The authors conclude that participatory photovoice can expand definitions of transition readiness beyond clinical autonomy to include familial and community responsibilities, and they call for explicit reporting of interpretive authority in photovoice research. The study also supports beginning transition preparation in early adolescence. Further details, participant characteristics, and full analytic procedures are reported in the full manuscript and supplementary materials.